Fresh AfieldMore posts

Jackson Landers' Excellent Carp Adventure

Aug 30, 2011

I spent last Thursday with one of the most interesting people I have met in quite a while. Jackson Landers is a self-proclaimed “adult-onset hunter” who is rapidly turning his interest in wild edibles into a cottage industry. Landers has a blog, The Locavore Hunter and a new book, The Beginner’s Guide to Hunting Deer for Food. He also teaches workshops that show urban/suburbanites how to turn backyard wildlife into table fare and makes frequent appearances in the New York Times. His latest project is a book that he hopes will transform the local-foods movement into a brigade to combat invasive species.

Knowing his interest in this last topic, I offered him the chance to catch, clean and eat some of Missouri’s distressingly abundant invasive carp. He jumped on that offer like a silver carp into a motorboat. Thursday morning found us motoring up the Blackwater River in a Conservation Department shocking boat, nets at the ready. Vince Travnichek, who supervises MDC’s Missouri River Field Station, was at the helm.

It took us maybe 15 minutes to gather enough silver carp to feed a large family. It was kind of silly using nets to catch fish; they kept jumping into the boat on their own, sometimes landing right in the holding tank. We kept at it until around noon to see if we could catch at least one bighead carp, but no luck. Back in the kitchen, Vince quickly turned half a dozen silver carp and one common carp into fillets and other cookable cuts and launched an invasive carp eat-athon that left us all stuffed to the…gills.

First up were deep-fried fillets that Vince had scored deeply with a knife before breading. Deep cuts in the meat exposes the many bones for which carp are infamous to hot oil, tenderizing all but the largest ones.

Next were buffalo ribs, so named because they normally are made from buffalo fish. In this case, the raw material was common carp. This critter is another invasive import, though we tend to forget that because it has been mucking up the United States’ waters since 1831. Vince cut out sections of flesh with one rib in each, the breaded and fried them, creating a fish stick with its own handle.

Then he chopped up a bunch of silver-carp fillets in a food processor. By mixing resulting slurry with mashed potatoes, commercial breading mix and Cajun seasoning, Vince created balls similar to hushpuppies. To be honest, I didn’t care for the gooey centers, but the crust was tasty.

Finally, Vince used a slightly different mix of breading and chopped-up carp to make patties. These were firmer on the inside than the fishballs and quite flavorful, but I found the chopped-up bones bothersome.

Last time I ate an invasive carp it was a 20-pound grass carp from Manito Lake south of Tipton. I smoked it whole, then boned the cooked flesh as best I could and ran it through a meat grinder before forming it into patties like crab cakes and frying them. At the time, I thought it was very good, but that might just be because I was personally invested in the endeavor.

Anyway, I hope Landers can get lots of people eating invasive carp. They seem to have replaced native species as the most common critters in the Missouri River and its tributaries. I think just about everyone would prefer to see the plankton that are these invading carps’ staple food turned into catfish, paddlefish, buffalo and other fish that belong in Missouri’s streams.

-Jim Low-


A silver carp goes airborne just as Jackson Landers nets another fish.
Landing a Silver Carp
Just as author Jackson Landers netted a silver carp, another invasive carp went airborne nearby.


Jackson Landers holds a silver carp in one hand and a common carp in the other.
For a Fistful of Carp
Author Jackson Landers netted silver carp (left) and common carp (right) to fill the menu during his trip to Missouri.


Vince Travnichek and Jackson Landers prepare invasive carp for cooking.
Invasive Carp Cleaning
Big Rivers Field Science Station Supervisor Vince Travnichek, left, showed author Jackson Landers how to break down invasive carp for easiest cooking.


Scored fish fillets are ready for breading and cooking.
Ready for the Pan
Deep scoring cuts carp bones into small pieces, allowing hot oil to tenderize them during cooking.


Fried golden brown, these carp fillets are tempting morsels.
Tempting Morsels
Deep-fried in peanut oil, these silver carp fillets were tempting morsels.


These ground fish patties are ready for the table.
Ground-fish patties
One of Vince Travnichek's invasive carp recipes uses patties made of ground fillets, breading and seasoning. Pan-frying completes the process.


thanks for sharing the info.that is interesting.

Thanks for your comments, Virginia & Jerry. I know from past experience that not many folks own pressure cookers, and even fewer have pressure canners. The idea is to get large numbers of people to eat Asian carp, so we need to find easy ways to cook them. As for fertillizer, I asked about that, and apparently the price you can get for that purpose isn't enough to make it worthwhile for commercial anglers to harvest them. Landers and some associates are working on setting up a commercial processing plant to turn Asian carp into something like fish sticks. That might eventually work.

If you pressure cook the carp in canning jars,the bones are no longer an issue,the larger bones will soften to the point of being edible like those in canned salmon.

If you can't beat 'em, eat 'em. Seriously, because I think off the wall a lot, I've wondered if silver carp could be economically harvested and turned into fertilizer. Native Americans did it, why can't modern Americans?

Recent Posts

white-lined sphinx larva

Mysteries of the Sphinx Moths

Sep 08, 2019

They rest like a sphinx, hover like a hummingbird, flutter like a bat, and are built for speed like a plane.  Sphinx moths have an identity crisis.  With us, not them.  Many are mistaken for other species. Discover more in this week's Discover Nature Notes.

Common Nighthawk

Flying Bullbats

Sep 02, 2019

Watch for creatures known as flying "bullbats" in Missouri's September skies. Common Nighthawks fly like bats and make booming dives at dawn and dusk on their southern migration. Hear what they sound like and why their name makes no sense in this week's Discover Nature Note.

Niangua Darter

The Hummingbirds of the Fish World

Aug 25, 2019

Darters have been called the hummingbirds of the fish world. See their flash-and-dash, and travel streamside to discover the Niangua darter, a fish found only in Missouri, in this week's Discover Nature Note.